Explore tens of thousands of sets crafted by our community.
Cultural Relativism
29
Flashcards
0/29
Ethnocentrism Rejection
Cultural relativism rejects ethnocentrism, the practice of judging another culture by the standards of one's own culture, advocating for understanding and constructive cultural interactions.
Definition of Cultural Relativism
Cultural Relativism is the philosophical view that all ethical and moral systems are equally valid, and that the truth or justification of moral judgments is not absolute but relative to the cultural context from which they originate.
Challenge in Moral Judgments Across Cultures
Cultural relativism poses that it is challenging to make moral judgments about the beliefs or practices in a culture different from one's own, since such judgments are grounded in an external cultural context.
Ethical Diversity
Cultural relativism recognizes the diversity of moral systems and the potential fruitfulness of various ethical perspectives, promoting tolerance for such diversity.
Moral Truths Are Culture-Dependent
In cultural relativism, moral truths are not universal but instead depend on cultural beliefs and practices, meaning what's considered morally right in one culture could be wrong in another.
No Universal Moral Standard
Cultural relativism argues that there is no single, objective standard for judging ethical behaviour since moral standards are created by cultures and societies.
Cultural Determinism
Cultural determinism, often associated with cultural relativism, suggests that an individual's beliefs and behaviors are predominantly determined by their culture.
Problem of Moral Progress
Critics of cultural relativism argue that it provides no objective basis for moral progress since it implies all cultural moral systems are equally valid, making it difficult to argue for social or moral reforms.
Inability to Condemn Cultural Practices
Due to its principle of moral systems' equality, cultural relativism faces challenges in condemning practices that are widely seen as harmful, such as human rights violations, within certain cultures.
Culture vs. Individual Autonomy
Cultural relativism can undermine the importance of individual autonomy and ethical pluralism within cultures by focusing too heavily on the collective cultural norms.
Cross-Cultural Objective Values
Some philosophers argue that despite the diversity of cultures, certain ethical values may be objectively valuable and recognized cross-culturally, which cultural relativism might overlook.
Cultural Relativism and Human Rights
The compatibility of cultural relativism with universal human rights is questionable as the latter presumes certain rights are inalienable irrespective of cultural context.
Issues with Cultural Essentialism
Cultural relativism can inadvertently endorse cultural essentialism, the idea that all members of a culture share certain characteristics, which is often criticized as being reductive and ignoring intra-cultural diversity.
Misconceptions of Cultural Immutability
Cultural relativism can mistakenly be interpreted as suggesting that cultures are static and immutable, whereas in reality, cultures are dynamic and constantly evolving.
Limits of Moral Relativism
There are practical limits to moral relativism since some cultural practices, such as those involving violence or oppression, evoke strong resistance and calls for reform from within and outside the culture.
Problems with Defining 'Culture'
Cultural relativism's arguments often hinge on nebulous definitions of 'culture,' making it problematic when cultures overlap, change, or have internal disagreements.
The Role of Anthropologists
Cultural relativism often draws from anthropological studies, suggesting that anthropologists have a nonjudgmental approach to cultural analysis, yet this position may sometimes prevent critical engagement with ethical issues.
Social Cohesion and Cultural Practices
Cultural relativism can emphasize the role of cultural practices in maintaining social cohesion and understanding societal organization, even at the cost of overlooking problematic aspects.
Moral Objectivity vs. Cultural Sensitivity
Critics of cultural relativism highlight the conflict between upholding moral objectivity and the desire to be culturally sensitive and respectful of cultural differences.
Impossibility of Pure Objectivity
Critics argue that cultural relativism fails because pure objectivity in cultural assessment is impossible, as evaluators are invariably influenced by their own cultural backgrounds.
Relativism vs. Moral Realism
Cultural relativism is at odds with moral realism, which holds that there are objective moral truths that can be discovered and apply to all cultures, regardless of differing views.
Contradiction in the Concept of Tolerance
Cultural relativism's call for tolerance can contradict itself, as total cultural tolerance would require accepting intolerant cultural practices, which itself is intolerant.
Practicality in Inter-Cultural Dialogue
Proponents of cultural relativism assert that it fosters greater understanding in inter-cultural communication and dialogues by discouraging the imposition of one's own cultural standards onto others.
Moral Isolationism
Cultural relativism can lead to moral isolationism, the idea that we can never fully understand nor ethically evaluate another culture, which can create barriers to moral discourse and action.
Dispute Over Cultural Superiority
Cultural relativism aims to dispel the notion of cultural superiority, yet some argue that this very denial of superiority may inhibit objective assessment of cultural practices and their consequences.
The 'Right' to Cultural Integrity
Cultural relativism can imply that cultures have a right to maintain their integrity and resist external pressures, but it raises questions about how this right interacts with individuals' rights within that culture.
Critique of Overgeneralization
Cultural relativism can lead to the overgeneralization of cultural attributes, failing to acknowledge individual diversity and the existence of subcultures within a larger cultural context.
Extreme Relativism and Social Fragmentation
An extreme form of cultural relativism may lead to social fragmentation, as it could discourage shared values that are crucial for societal unity and cooperation.
Cultural Change and Globalization
Cultural relativism may struggle to accommodate the complex ways in which cultures change and intermingle in the context of globalization and mass communication.
© Hypatia.Tech. 2024 All rights reserved.