Discover published sets by community

This debate concerns the ethical implications of artificial intelligence and robotics, including issues of autonomy, accountability, and moral status. Discussions are ongoing, focusing on the development of ethical frameworks for AI and robotics.

This dispute involved the transition from an Earth-centered (geocentric) cosmology to a sun-centered (heliocentric) one. Galileo's defense of heliocentrism led to his trial and house arrest. The heliocentric model eventually became the accepted astronomical paradigm.

The demarcation problem discusses the criteria for distinguishing between science and non-science. Karl Popper's falsifiability criterion proposed that scientific statements must be refutable. No definitive solution to the problem has been agreed upon.

Thomas Kuhn's book proposed that science progresses through paradigm shifts rather than cumulative knowledge. The concept of incommensurability challenges the idea of a linear scientific progress and has been influential and controversial in the philosophy of science.

The discussion focuses on whether non-human animals experience consciousness and to what degree. While there is growing evidence of complex behaviors and cognitive abilities in animals, the subjective nature of consciousness keeps the debate unsettled.

The cause of dinosaur extinction is debated, with theories including asteroid impact, volcanic activity, and climate change. The consensus now favors an asteroid impact as the primary trigger for the dinosaurs' mass extinction.

Alfred Wegener proposed the theory of continental drift, suggesting that continents move across the Earth's surface. Initially rejected, the concept later gained acceptance with the development of plate tectonics that provided a mechanism for the movement.

This debate questions the relative importance of genetics (nature) and environment (nurture) in determining individual characteristics and behaviors. Modern understanding emphasizes a complex interaction between genes and environment, with no clear-cut resolution.

Proposed by James Lovelock, the Gaia Hypothesis suggests that Earth's biological and geological components interact in a complex system, maintaining conditions suitable for life. The hypothesis remains controversial but has stimulated research into Earth system science.

The spontaneous generation debate questioned whether life can arise from non-living matter. Experiments by Louis Pasteur that invalidated the theory for microorganisms led to the widespread acceptance of biogenesis.

Several interpretations of quantum mechanics exist, including the Copenhagen interpretation, many-worlds, and hidden variables theories. The debate focuses on the nature of reality and causality at the quantum level, without a universally accepted resolution.

August Weismann proposed that germ plasm (genetic material) is separate from somatic cells and does not age, thus maintaining continuity through generations. Debated in his time, this concept has influenced understanding of heredity, but has been refined with the discovery of DNA and genetic mutation.

This debate involves the validity of race as a biological concept. Modern genetics and the human genome project have shown that genetic diversity within populations is greater than between them, which has led to an understanding of race as a social construct rather than a scientific category.

This thought experiment in philosophy questions if one can know the reality of their own existence. It posits that a brain could be in a vat, connected to a supercomputer that simulates experiences. The debate has implications for epistemology, but remains unsolved.

The global warming controversy includes debates over the causes, severity, and consequences of climate change. There is a scientific consensus that global warming is primarily caused by human activities, but policy responses vary widely.

C.P. Snow's 'Two Cultures' lecture highlighted a divide between the sciences and humanities. The ongoing debate discusses the implications of this divide for education and intellectual life, with no definitive resolution of the tension between the two cultures.

The nature of light has been debated as either a wave or a particle. Thomas Young's double-slit experiment supported the wave model, while Einstein's photoelectric effect provided evidence for the particle model. Quantum mechanics reconciled these views with wave-particle duality.

Vitalism argued that living organisms possess a 'vital force' that non-living entities do not. Friedrich Wöhler's synthesis of urea, an organic compound, from inorganic substances challenged this concept, leading to the decline of vitalism in favor of mechanism.

Debate concerning whether scientific theories represent reality or are merely instruments for prediction. The realist perspective views theories as true descriptions, while instrumentalism sees them as tools. The debate continues without a definitive consensus.